barbara walker's homepage
RESEARCH
FRENCH POLYNESIA
My research in French Polynesia involves two interrelated projects. The first is a study of the relationships between gender and work in the process of economic restructuring. In particular, I am concerned with how women are being articulated into French Polynesia's new economy precipitated by the end of the nuclear testing era. I argue that women's economic opportunities are shaped and limited by the economic imperatives of the new development plan, in addition to historical representations of what Polynesian women do in society.

French Polynesia has been a colony of France since 1843. Prior to the 1960s, French Polynesia's national economy was based on meager exports of copra, vanilla, coffee, and phosphate. Local people made their livelihoods through subsistence farming and fishing, in addition to petty marketing of agricultural and other commodities.

After Algeria gained its independence in 1962, France shifted its nuclear test program from the Saharan Desert to French Polynesia, which marked a surge in economic development in French Polynesia, particularly in the Society Islands. An airport and shipping ports were built at Papeete on reclaimed reefs to handle the transfer of people and equipment for the nuclear test sites on the atolls of Moruroa and Fangataufa, as well as a support base on Hao Atoll and the headquarters in Papeete. The construction of this infrastructure opened the gates for tourism to enter the region.

In 1993, the government of French Polynesia launched Le Pacte de Progres (The Pact of Progress), a ten-year economic development plan which aims to achieve local economic self-sufficiency based on tourism, agriculture, and fishing. It is speculated that by 2003 military incomes will have ceased, and in 2006 France will begin the process of withdrawing the massive subsidies and metropolitan transfers which were necessary to achieve local acquiescence to the 179 nuclear detonations between 1966 and 1995.

Development projects undertaken by Le Pacte de Progres on Moorea are largely related to export agriculture and tourism. These include subsidised loans for pineapple farmers, the construction of a new 150-room resort hotel, and loans to tour companies for the purchase of new vehicles and boats for increasing numbers of tourists (particularly from two new 700 passenger cruise ships which visit Moorea for two days each every ten days).

Women have largely entered the new economy as cheap and unskilled workers. Because of increasing inflation and a new sales tax, many women have been forced to abandon subsistence and petty market production to work for wages. In agriculture, women are most often employed as pickers, sorters, and processors, frequently as free labor for their husbands or fathers. In the tourism sector, women work mostly as servers, housekeepers, and entertainers.

I suggest that the low status of women in Moorea's labor market is supported in part by images of Polynesian women which were historically invented by European explorers, missionaries, and artists. In these images, Polynesian women were depicted as passive, under-employed, langourous, exotic, and existing only to serve or entertain foreigners.

This excerpt from French Polynesia's Ministry of Tourism Travel Planner brochure (1999, p. 12) is one illustration of how the government has manipulated European representations of Polynesian people to promote the new economy.
In my second project, I am studying the process and effects of establishing a system of marine protected areas (MPAs) in Moorea's lagoon. In conjunction with the goals of Le Pacte de Progres, the government has designed MPA systems in the lagoons of Moorea and Bora Bora, which are the two most visited islands by tourists. Responding to concerns about overfishing, the government is attempting to preserve one of the principal environments that tourist expect to experience in French Polynesia: the abundant underwater world of the tropical coral reef ecosystem.

The MPA designation process has exacerbated existing conficts and tensions among Moorea's fishing community, largely related to a growing scarcity of fish and increased costs of living. Throughout the lengthy process of designing the MPAs, a series of maps showing various potential MPA sites was published in a daily newspaper. These maps served to further politicize the MPAs, and incited physical violence and property damage among fishers. In addition, conflicts arose among and between the state, hotels, and lagoon tour operators over the definitions and spatial parameters of lagoon habitats, ecology, and management.

To create the controversial maps, a database of lagoon information was created by the Ministry of Urbanism which included a base map of the island and its reef crest, and data on a variety of lagoon uses and features. The maps produced by the government seemed "scientific" and "official," making them difficult to refute by stakeholders. Yet many of the data layers were based on inadequate data. For instance, none of the data layers included measurements of lagoon use in terms of temporal or economic value; and no data were available on lagoon substrates or habitats which would have been helpful in siting the MPAs in relation to variations in lagoon ecology and use. The use of these maps in the PGEM decision-making meetings limited the ability of many stakeholders to insert their cognition of the marine environment into the maps or the decision-making process. In addition, stakeholders felt that important uses and meanings of the lagoon - such as the non-economic value and the spiritual meanings associated with certain areas - could not be identified, quantified, or mapped within the confines of a digital database, or on an analog map for that matter. Stakeholders voiced anger and frustration at not having access to, or knowledge of the computer mapping technology used. At the same time, stakeholders were reluctant to provide their own data to the PGEM policy-makers because they did not trust the state to input or analyze their marine knowledge fairly in the GIS.

In sum, Gary Larsen's take on fishing management is all too apt in the case of French Polynesia.

My research in Moorea from 2001-2003 will addresses the cultural, economic, and ecological efficacy of the MPAs, to examine how economic development, an increase in population, and changes in consumption patterns affect the use, conservation, and degradation of lagoons. Four types of data will be analyzed: socio-economic, ecological, geo-spatial, and historical. In addition, this project will facilitate the creation of a community-based Geographic Information System (GIS), in which all lagoon users will have the opportunity to create, up-date, disseminate, and acquire knowledge about the lagoon in a spatial context. Collaborators include:

Eric Edlund, Assistant Professor,
Department of Geography, University of Montana at Missoula

Rick Wilder, M.S.
Department of Ecology, Evolution, and Marine Biology, University of California at Santa Barbara

Dr. Yannick Chancerelle and Prof. René Galzin
Centre de Recherches et Observatoire de l'Environnement (CRIOBE), Moorea

The Richard B. Gump South Pacific Research Station of the University of California at Berkeley, Moorea

 

This research has been supported by the National Science Foundation (SBR-9806256 and SBR-0137458), the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation Program on Global Security and Sustainability (Grant 00-65195-GSS); and a UCSB National Center for Geographic Information and Analysis (NCGIA) Public Participation GIS Seed Grant.

barbara walker's homepage

© copyright 2001 by Barbara Walker